'It is better to light a candle than curse the darkness' Proverb
Showing posts with label Environmental issues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Environmental issues. Show all posts

Sunday, 21 June 2020

Mini Film Review: Planet of the Humans


Planet of the Humans is an American environmental documentary written, directed, and produced by Jeff Gibbs, and supported and promoted by Michael Moore.  First released in 2019 in was then released onto YouTube by Moore in April 2020 as part of Earth Day's 50th Anniversary, before being promptly taken down again in May due to claims of copyright infringement.  Due to this removal, I wasn't sure if it would be worth making a review about this film, but as it could be made available again in the future (after editing) I thought I would still write about my thoughts on it.

Looking at the renewable energy industry, the documentary questions whether it can actually solve the issue of our ever-increasing resources consumption and in fact argues that green energy is not actually sustainable at all.  It is this and its attack on some of the most famous environmental campaigners, such as Al Gore, that has made this movie so controversial and sparked a backlash in the climate change community.

There are some glaring issues with the movie, mainly the number of out of date facts and footage used to make their point.  These include stating that solar panels only convert 8% of the energy they receive into electricity when, with modern panels, it's actually now 15 to 20%.  These newer panels are also a lot cheaper to produce and buy and are therefore much more available to people than before.  Then there's the claim that renewable energy still needs to be backed up by fossil fuels to ensure there is a constant supply of electricity.  This may be the case in some countries, but you only have to look at somewhere like Iceland to see what is actually possible when using a variety of renewable resources.  It also stated that the carbon footprint of renewables is either similar or in fact worse than fossil fuels, but there is a wealth of research that shows that this is just not the case especially with the most modern systems.  These are just a few of the inaccuracies found in the movie, but I didn't want to spend this whole post listing them.

However, it would be inaccurate to say that there weren't some truths in this documentary as well.  Firstly, we can't just rely on technology to get us out of this climate change hole without having to make any changes at all to our lifestyles.  We will need to change how we do things and reduce the amount of energy and resources we use on a daily basis.  You can not sustainably live an infinite lifestyle on a finite planet.  Secondly, solar and wind technologies do need to use rare minerals to produce them, pretty much everything technological does, and collecting these as virgin materials is very destructive to the ecosystems they are found in.  However, there are ways around this and this is definitely an area where we need to get better at recycling the precious resources we use.  Thirdly, that destroying woodlands to produce biomass energy is definitely not a good thing and not only takes away one of our best carbon dioxide absorbers but also damages the surrounding soil health and has a negative impact on water retention.  We definitely shouldn't be using that type of biomass, however, there are many other forms quick are much more sustainable and can be used effectively. 

Perhaps the biggest point they make, though it's more of a side statement which isn't given much air time, is that large elephant in the environmental room of population size.  I know people baulk at the idea of talking about it and even see it as a form of eugenics, but it is one of the most fundamental ways in which we can reduce the impact we are and will have on our planet.  Of course, it has to voluntary and the most effective way of doing it is actually empowering women - something not talked about in this documentary.

Filling your documentary with lots of out of date inaccuracies is probably not the best way of getting your point across and I can see why a lot of climate sceptics have felt that this film has given them something to cheers about, whilst climate activists have gone against it.  However, perhaps the good thing about this film is it opens up an important conversation we need to have about our consumption habits and lifestyle choices.  It's very unlikely that we can just carry on with the status quo and get away with it.  Oh, and of course, checking facts that are presented to you.

One other thing I just wanted to add was that it did make me wonder a little bit about supporting 350.org based on the interviews they had with Bill McKibben.  Obviously, there was editing involved, but he didn't come across particularly well in this.  I don't want to judge the organisation entirely on this film, but I do think I'm going to do a little bit more research on 350.org before I start donating to them.

I would say that, if you can find it, do watch the movie.  Just make sure you have a search engine open beside you so you can do some fact-checking when you do.

Sunday, 15 September 2019

The Concept of Shifting Baseline Syndrome


I have a very specific memory from the beginning of this year which keeps cropping up in my head.  It's the memory of the strong feeling I had when I had finished working in a beautiful Caledonian pinewood and started work in an area of land that is managed for grouse shooting.  The conspicuous contrast in the amount of life you could see and hear in these two habitats was very evident  and made me think about the other moorlands I drive and walk through a lot in Scotland.  Knowing as I do that Caledonian pinewoods used to cover large areas of Scotland before cutting, burning, and grazing depleted them to just 1% of their original extent, it's made me realise just how 'unnatural' a lot of the Scottish landscape actually is.


And yet many people don't see it as unnatural at all.  They see it as rugged and wild, untamed and one of the last natural places in Britain, completely unaware of just how managed it is.  I know this as I used to be one of these people and it made me wonder about how it is that we can be seeing a landscape so falsely?  How are we not seeing nature as damaged as it actually is?  So I did what I always do when I have questions and started researching, and during my research I came across the concept of Shifting Baseline Syndrome.


The idea of Shifting Baseline first appeared in a landscape architect's, Ian McHarg, publication 'Design with Nature' in 1969 when he was comparing modern landscapes with that in which ancient people used to live.  Shifting Baseline Syndrome was then coined by a marine biologist called Daniel Pauly in 1995 when writing about the fact that fisheries management scientist tended to use the population size of fish populations at the beginning of their careers as the baseline for stock management rather than at its untouched state as the baseline for stock management.  This meant that inaccurate advice was then being provided as the baseline was much lower then it should actually be.  


However, this is not just confined to fisheries management but is actually a common problem when it comes to how people view the natural world around them.  As we believe that what we remember from our childhood is when nature was at its normal, most natural state, we pay little attention to what we perceive as a slight loss unaware that it was already depleted in the first place.  This new level of depleted wildness then becomes the new baseline for the next generation.  A good example of this is the lost of a rare species.  When they go extinct it is taken as a sad but unsurprising loss, the population size was after all already small.  However, they are forgetting that the population size of many of these species actually used to be quite large, but declining with each generation.  This decline was so gradual that we basically sleepwalked into the situation.


This concept is now being increasingly recognised as one of the fundamental obstacles faced by conservation organisations when trying to address the wide range of global environmental issues we face today.  Trying to get individuals to care about an issue when they only see a relatively minor change is difficult and education is greatly needed to help people see just how far the baseline has shifted, even within a few generations.  Then we can have a more realistic eye opening conversation about the problems we're facing and the actions we need to take to solve them.


Don't get me wrong, I still find the stark Scottish scenery beautiful, but this beauty is tempered by the fact that I know I should also being seeing large woodlands in that scenery.  And I have to admit, in my eyes at least, it would be all the more beautiful for it.

Sunday, 25 August 2019

Podcasts I'm Listening To - Learning Whilst Moving


At the moment my work means that I am do two long drives (around 3 hours each) a week in areas where radio reception is very poor at best.  Whilst I have been using some of this time to listen to the CDs I have left to decide whether or not I really want to keep them, it also seemed like a perfect time to do a little bit more learning by listening to some podcasts.  These are the ones I've found so far and listen to on a regular basis.


  • No Such Thing As A Fish - produced and presented by the QI Elves, this is a weekly podcast where they each bring up their favourite fact for that week.  As you can imagine, it's very educational but it's also very, very funny and I often find myself laughing out loud as I drive - something that's probably very disconcerting to other drivers around me.  The thing I love most about this show is that they talk about things I wouldn't normal think to look up and so I learn so much more than I would just left to my own devises.
  • The Ground Up Show -  this is one of the first podcasts that I actually started listening to on a regular basis and is produced and presented by Matt D'Avella (who I also watch on YouTube).  Here Matt talks to different creators about the processes they use and what they've learnt along the way.  It's obviously not as facts based as No Such Thing As A Fish and not every podcast feels like it's necessarily relavent to me.  However, I've still learnt things from each show, even when I wasn't expecting to, and I like the relaxed feel of Matt and his guest talking.  It's particularly interesting to learn about how each individual overcome something they were going through to get to where they are today - a nice little reminder that not everyone always has it together all the time.
  • Science Vs - is another facts based podcast and will also have you unexpectedly laughing at topics.  This is a Gimlet podcast and it takes all the trends and opinions that are out there at the moment and breaks them down using facts.  The subjects can be very varied from week to week and can be quite hard hitting.  And, again, I like the fact that I'll be listening about subjects I wouldn't normally choose to look up myself.  I'm finding handing this decision to someone else a very useful tool.  Probably my favourite one so far has been about Sharks and the completely misguided information that has been put out about them.  Like the idea they can smell a drop of blood in a swimming pool - not actually true apparently.
  • Nature's Voice - this is the RSPB's podcast.  Produced on a monthly basis I've found it a pretty good way of getting the latest information about current, mostly bird but also other wildlife news.  They also have little features and interviews with people working in the field and, whilst most of the ones I've listened to so far have been UK based, this is information about projects going on further afield as well.  It is quite a dry podcast, but I don't mind that.
  • Pulse of the Planet - this is a really lovely little podcast, and I say little because each show is only 2 minutes long.  Produced daily, you get a sound portrait of Planet Earth covering the rhymes of nature, culture, and science.  The subjects vary greatly and you can find yourself listening to serenading moths one day and a Texas rodeo the next.
  • Normal To Nomad - is a pretty new podcast (they first uploaded on the 16th July 2019) and is produced and presented by Elsa Rhae and Barron Link.  I actually found these guys on YouTube as well where they've been documenting their life in the US living in a Scamp with their dog Kamp.  They only have five shows up at the moment, but it looks like they'll be posting on a weekly basis so this'll add up quickly.  There is lots of information on their channel about living this type of lifestyle, but I love how specific these podcasts are, honing in on one specific subject.  It works well with the more varied subjects they cover on their YouTube videos.  I'm glad they've started podcasting.

There are some new podcasts that I've started listening to and am enjoying so far but can't really give a proper review about.  They are:
  • Sustainable World Radio - Ecology and Permaculture Podcast - I've only listened to one episode of this, which was an interview with Dr Monica Gagliano about her research into plant cognition, but it was interesting and not a subject I would necessarily have picked so I'm keen to listen to more.
  • Warming Signs - this podcast looks at the most pressing environmental issues of the moment, interviewing experts and using facts to look at what's really going on.  One of the shortest podcasts on this list, I've found this a really good, unbiased way of learning a little bit more about the subjects I'm interested in.
  • Sustainababble - I've only listened to two episodes of this podcast and already I love it.  Very funny, but full of facts and information, this is a weekly podcast that looks at a variety of environmental issues and exposing what they call 'eco-guffs'.  Definitely worth a listen and I'm looking forward to the next one.
I've also been finding myself listening to these podcasts as I potter around the hostel I'm staying at whilst sorting out my gear and getting ready for the next day.  It's a great way to give myself something interesting to do whilst carrying out those mindless tasks.  What's not to love about that.  Oh, and if you're wondering, I listen to them on Google Podcasts.  At least for now.

Sunday, 30 September 2018

Brexit and the Environment


So here we are, the six month count down to us officially leaving the EU has started and whilst all the talk all over the media has been about immigration and business I've been wondering about the environment (a particularly vague subject when it comes to the information we've been getting).  Information has been scares and without any final outcomes from the talks yet it's difficult to know exactly where the environment stands on this Government's agenda.



There are some things to be positive about, such as the fact that the UK Government has actually been one of the main driving forces at setting higher climate change ambitions and in attempted to green up the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP).  This government has made quite a few noises about a 'greener Brexit' producing their 25 Year Environmental Plan (25YEP) in January of this year and lots of positive noises coming from ministers' speeches with Teresa May insisting the Brexit will not mean the lowering of environmental standards.  This could also be seen as an opportunity to improve what are now the CAP and Common Fisheries Policy (CFP), both of which are associated with environmental problems and unsustainable overproduction.  



However, the Conservative Party hasn't exactly got a great reputation when it comes to the environment and climate change, with a number of their politicians hinting that this Government, despite the rhetoric, is actually wanting to lax the policies we already have in place.  In fact, our own Environment Secretary, Michael Grove, stated that he believes the EU Bird Directive and Habitats Directive should be reformed or overturned once we leave the EU. Worrying.  And then there's the 25YEP.  On the surface it seems good (it's 155 pages and quite dry, but stick with it), but then you look at it closely it's pretty vague on details with a lot of lovely sounding goals and not a lot of information on how we're going to get there or what is going to be put in place to ensure they happen.  Call be cynical but I don't really trust politicians when it comes to words without any backing.



So here are the things that I'm worrying about:
  • CAP and CFP.  As I've said before, whilst there have been attempts to improve both of these policies throughout the EU, there has been some issues with how 'green' and sustainable they have been and leaving the EU could be a great opportunity for us to improve on these in the UK.  As always we are getting mixed messages from the politicians on this one, but the thing that worries me to most is trade.  It sounds weird I know, but here's the thing.  If (or more probably when) we open our market up to more people other then the EU we will open the probability that we will be seeing products from other areas which are much cheaper due to their lower standards in environmental and social polices, undercutting our domestic products.  Whilst I would love to believe that we as a nation would support our homegrown products by buying the more expensive, more environmentally friendly items we all know how that is actually going to go.  The result is likely to be a lowering of our environmental policies to allow domestic trade to compete with the international trade.  Not only would this mean no improvements on CAP and CFP, but a reduction in the policies we already have in place.
  • Fighting Climate Change.  On the surface this is an area we possibly don't need to worry too much about, after all we are part of a number of international commitments, including the United Nations Framework Convention of Climate Change (UNFCC - you would think they would find a shorter name), have our own UK Climate Change Act (CCA) 2008, and an independent Climate Change Committee (CCC) which advises our government.  However, the EU has much stricter goals and timescales then the international community, and acts as a way of keeping track of our progress as well as providing the proverbial stick whenever we fail in the goals set.  Whilst the CCC is great at advising the government it has no actual enforcement powers to ensure we actually carry out the work needed, and this means that there is no real incentive to actually fight climate change once we leave the EU.
  • The EU Birds Directive and EU Habitats Directive.  Unlike climate change there is no real international agreement on these which could hold the UK accountable.  Whilst we do have sites that are classified as SSSIs (Sites of Special Scientific Interest) they don't necessarily stop development in the same way these EU Directives have done (anyone remember that particular golf course built on part of Foveran Links, a SSSI site in Aberdeenshire, which is now 'partially destroyed').  The RSPB have suggested in a Guardian article that since the Natura 2000 and Habitats Directive have come into place they have reduced the loss of protected sites from 15% per year to just 1%.  The loss of these will be quite a blow and this is perhaps the area where the most pressure will need to be put on the Government to ensure that these areas remain protected after 2019 with policies that don't just fall away when money and development come knocking.
  • Funding.  The UK has received a large amount of funding from the EU for research.  Figures from The Royal Society has shown that we received 8.8 million Euro between 2007 - 2013 and Greenpeace has shown that in the EU budget for 2014 - 2020 the UK will have received around 5.8 million Euro to funding projects supporting the environment and the fight against climate change.  This funding will need to found from the UK's own coffers and the worry that the money may be put 'to better use' reducing our ability to help protect our environment both locally and globally.
  • Accountability.  Perhaps the thing that worries me the most is who is going to hold us accountable.  Whilst we are in the EU we have standards we have to adhere to and which are monitored and scrutinised with all the necessary reports.  There is no hiding what we are doing or not so subtly looking the other way, and if we do not adhere to these standards then there is the Court of Justice of the European Union, an independent justice service that can fine us substantial amounts for failing to comply.  One example of this happened at the beginning of this year when the UK failed to comply with EU air quality laws.  To ensure we stay on track when it comes to climate change and environmental protection we have to ensure that a new, independent watchdog is put in place which is able to work over all four UK countries and has the power and resources to be able to scrutinise and enforce the policies put in place.

One article I found particularly interesting in my research into Brexit and the environment was put together by Friends of the Earth on 'UK Environmental Policy Post-Brexit: A Risk Analysis'.  This report looks at the possible risk to the environment of five possible Brexit scenarios as well as the implications on Environmental Protection.  Whilst this covered most of the areas I'd already been looking at the one things it reminded me of, and which I had forgotten about, is that the UK has a devolved Government.  This is especially true when it comes to policies on energy, agriculture, and fisheries and this could be a sticking point when it comes to the UK Government putting together environmental policies after we have left the EU.  'In fighting' between the separate Governments could mean that areas remain unprotected for extended periods of time whilst the policies are put intp place and there is even more of a distraction from reaching our climate goals then already exists with the work on Brexit.  Not really something we can afford to do.



So these are my worries about us leaving the EU and what I've noticed so far in the proceedings when it comes to the environment and climate change.  Please let me know if you think I've missed anything when it comes to these issues and if there are any articles you think I should read - I'm always up for learning more.  From what I can see it'll be a waiting game until Brexit actually happens......and then we might have a fight on our hands to help protect our most valuable resource.



Sunday, 11 March 2018

Book Review: Inglorious


I should probably point out that I’m a little bit behind with this book as it came out in 2015, but as the issues it covers are still relevant today it seemed still a worthwhile book to read.  And it was.

The author, Mark Avery, used to work for the RSPB and was involved in the talks between NGOs and the shooting community (predominantly grouse shooting) on the issue of raptor persecution, which failed to have any results.  Now that he’s retired from the RSPB he is less effected by the need for diplomacy and is able to give a more blunt look at the effects of grouse shooting on our countryside.  Whilst this book is mainly about the persecution of hen harriers, especially on grouse shooting estates, it does look at the other impacts this one activity with all its upkeep has one the local environment.  

To be blunt, I have been against hunting my whole life and feel that it seems a very unpleasant way of having 'fun'.  As I’ve gotten older I’ve also become aware of the negative impact this sport is having on the surrounding environment, and the knock on effect this is having on our society as well.  I like to have a well formed argument in my head about the decisions I make and the opinions I have and this seemed like a good place to start when it comes to my ideas about grouse shooting.

The book itself feels more like reading a blog then a usual book, but this makes it very easy to read despite all the facts that come out of it.  It starts with details about hen harriers, OES through a very quick introduction to grouse shooting, and then goes over the various battles between those in conservation and those in shooting community. It ends with a hopeful idea of how all this would end with a future, fake interview with an ex- gamekeeper.  Most interesting for me was to find about the various studies that had occurred on this subject, especially the two Langholm Moor studies on the effects of hen harriers on grouse population size as well as the effect of diversionary feeding of the hen harriers, and the report by the League Against Cruel Sports based on an analysis by Sheffield Hallam University and Cormack Economics on the real financial benefits of grouse shooting.

This book hasn’t changed my mind on grouse shooting as a past time, obviously, but it has definitely helped me solidify my opinions on the activity and why I dislike it.  It has also helped to widen the holes in the arguments provided by the grouse shooting estates as to why this should be allowed to continue.

Firstly their argument that it has conservation value, especially for some wader species.  However, this looks a bit bland when you compare it to the illegal raptor removal, the legal other predator removal (including large numbers of foxes and stoats), the legal culling of hares as an additional tick carries, and the destruction and burning of habitats to produces ones most suitable for red grouse.  The pros most definitely do not out way the cons, and other work can be done to help sustain the numbers of waders we already have without needing to go to these extremes.


The second argument is that they bring needed finances to the areas in which they are located.  This is undoubtedly true, however so does tourism and the chance to see hen harriers and golden eagles would definitely be a draw to many people willing to put money into their journey.  As the analysis by Sheffield Hallam University and Cormack Economics showed it appears that the grouse shooting estates have overstated the actual size of this financial gain (possibly by as much as four times the actual figure).  When this is taken along with the fact that our taxes help pay for a good proportion of the upkeep through subsidies, the cost of the clean up after increased flooding (for which there is a connection with the destruction of peat bogs on grouse shooting estates), and the additional cost that will come from climate change (not helped here by the destruction of, again, peat bogs releasing large amounts of carbon normally stored here) the benefits are pretty small.


At the end of the day it is difficult to see grouse shooting as anything more then just an activity enjoyed by the very (rich) few and which has lead to the reduction or even loss of an number of species, the destruction of vital habitats with some negative impacts on the surrounding communities, and the loss of some amazing landscapes to the general public as a whole.  It may be enjoyable for those who get to do it, but Mark Avery can see no real benefit to it and neither can I.  Definitely a book worth reading.